I’ve been holding out on one more thing, and it’s kind of like the 800 lb gorilla in the room for me lately. How do I put this? I am currently trying to stay LDS, which means I am considering resigning. It feels at times like an actually physical struggle. It hurts in so many ways.
This is a hard thing to explain for many reasons, but in particular to those of you not LDS. Why is it a big deal? I would say to you that my identity is so wrapped up in being Mormon, that it would be like saying I don’t want to be a woman, or a mother, or wife. It’s that big to me. It is me. And to the Mormons, it sounds like I’m saying I want to go to hell.
Now before you go connecting the dots for me, let me say, I’ve had plenty of think time on the subject. In fact, there are days that the state of my soul and my faith is all I think about. All day long. It is exhausting. But I wanted to beat you to the punch before you tell me this somehow related to depression. I’m willing to admit it might be. I’m also willing to acknowledge that My Doubt (as it shall be known) became an issue well over a year ago, so about 6 months before the depression talk surfaced. So, I’m not sure that it’s not actually the other way around. I also know that even when I feel fine, My Doubt does not go away or magically resolve.
I realize that with this admission I will be talked about. By concerned family and friends, and my congregation for good or for bad. Perhaps I will become a cautionary tale of the hazards of too much hair dye and crazy dressing. Oh no! For the Mormon record, I am not engaged in any nefarious behavior. I am not associating with the wrong kind of people, and I am not reading anti-Mormon literature. I am thinking, reading, and feeling increasingly uncomfortable not just with the history of the church (that’s so 1990s), but with the church’s current direction.
The attention we’ve received as an institution for the past few years has made it difficult to escape to the faith room. The so-called Mormon Moment seems pretty long. Can 4 years really be a moment? I do think it’s good for us to examine and for our faith to mature. We get out of the black and white thinking and we venture into the grey. I’ve been in that grey area for a long time and it requires constant calibration. There are days I wish I could go back to the zealous faith of my youth, but then I remember the smug self-righteousness (not to mention the glaring inaccuracies) that encapsulated that time and I know I’d rather face hard decisions than be that person again. I think anything worth devoting yourself and your family to should be able to withstand your own scrutiny.
I’ve approached the topic with a few close friends, and the first thing people want to know is my list of issues. The problem for me is just how long that list is getting. I don’t want to enumerate my concerns via blogging – there are plenty of places online for robust discussion, should you be so inclined. (Also, I want to assure you that I will not be turning this into an anti-anything blog. It will still be my favorite self-indulgence spot.) As Mormons we place a huge emphasis on feelings – that is how I’ve been conditioned to find truth. So mental gymnastics aside, my feelings are what concern me most. I don’t feel anything when I’m at church, and I don’t feel anything when I pray. Where does that leave me? Continue reading →